FormFactor Stock: Disappointing Q1 Results, Value Erosion Risk (NASDAQ:FORM)

Right here on the Lab, in 2022, we already supplied a comps evaluation on two main firms within the probe sector Technoprobe S.p.A. (OTCPK:THNBY) our Clear Winner, and FormFactor (NASDAQ:FORM). After having analyzed the Q1 outcomes and 2023 expectations, we imagine that FormFactor is at the moment overvalued. Earlier than going deeper into the evaluation, you will need to report our newest publications on Infineon Applied sciences AG and STM. Each firms report a strong order backlog and within the final weeks, chip producers’ shares have been all up due to the nice indications coming from their newest press launch. What shocked probably the most the Wall Road investor neighborhood was the Micron president and CEO’s phrases. Intimately, he defined his confidence concerning the long-term earnings pattern and predicted that the reminiscence chip business will see a file 12 months in 2025 by way of market measurement thanks primarily to synthetic intelligence. On the identical time, inventories are enhancing and the highest supervisor expects gradual enhancements within the stability between provide and demand throughout the sector. This announcement was additionally backed by the German Infineon larger 2023 steerage. Probe playing cards are going to play into the AI phrases. Nvidia’s information heart’s robust efficiency is powered by semis (and the semiconductor must be verified earlier than commercialization).

Potential draw back

Apart from the financials comps evaluation that we’ll current afterward, there’s a unfavourable consideration to report. The Biden administration launched a sweeping set of export controls to restrict Chinese language semiconductor chips. These guidelines are set to restrict the Chinese language supercomputing techniques improvement and characterize the most important shift in US coverage towards know-how exports to China for the reason that Nineteen Nineties. This coverage might hamper China’s chip-making business; nonetheless, these restrictions will hit US firms which might be offering direct or oblique help to Chinese language enterprises concerned in superior semiconductor manufacturing. Intimately, the export will likely be prohibited for the Logic household parts with semis manufacturing nodes under 16 nanometers or recollections with manufacturing nodes under 18 nanometers. Different equipment elements used within the semis manufacturing course of can even be prohibited. Excessive-end probe playing cards are primarily used for exams on wafers linked to semis manufacturing, and right here on the Lab, we imagine that FormFactor is perhaps hit (and the newest gross sales information may already help this thesis). Then again, Technoprobe may benefit from this momentum and we’re not shocked to see that’s already growing its market share penetration.

Apart from the US restrictive regulation, for the sixth consecutive 12 months, Technoprobe was the best-rated provider within the tech satisfaction survey and was forward of FormFactor.

Q1 outcomes

This second half follows our earlier publication titled: “the story continued – Half 1“. Under are the primary takes from FormFactor’s newest monetary.

1. In 2022, Technoprobe gross sales reached €549 million and have been up by 40%, whereas FormFactor decreased its top-line gross sales by 2.8%, and in This autumn, turnover additional decelerated signing a minus of 19%. This unfavourable pattern was additionally confirmed in Q1, FormFactor income decreased by a further 15%. Happening to FormFactor P&L evaluation, each gross margin and EBITDA have been lower. Q1 web earnings considerably declined and reached solely $1.3 million;
2. Associated to level 1), FormFactor introduced that they “delivered income above the outlook vary towards a difficult business setting“. That is true; nonetheless, they weren’t in a position to decrease their working bills and their core margin additional declined;
3. Comparable unfavourable outcomes have been carried out within the web money circulate from working actions. Intimately, web money circulate was at $12.3 million in comparison with the $44.2 million achieved in the identical quarter final 12 months;
4. In Q1, key to notice is their respective Internet Money place, Technoprobe reached a web place of €404 million. On the present market cap, the money place represents 10% of the corporate’s worth whereas FormFactor’s money place stood at $235 million;
5. In This autumn, FormFactor forecasted a major gross margin enchancment and “a return to typical extra and out of date stock prices“. This was not in keeping with Q1 outcomes.

Fig 1

Fig 2

Conclusion and valuation

Our inside workforce is assured that each Technoprobe and FormFactor are secular winners as a result of optimistic semiconductor momentum. These optimistic traits are: 1) extra on a regular basis life electronics 2) extra know-how in our electronics (let’s take into consideration electrical toothbrushes with strain sensors) 3) 5G community developments, 4) information facilities, 5) extra semis within the automotive business each in BEV and ICE productions, 6) business 4.0 and sensible cities, and seven) AI. It’s key to recall that new semis are extra highly effective and smaller and this elevated probe card makes use of. As already talked about, testing will all the time be wanted and this can help FormFactor’s valuation. Nonetheless, trying on the numbers, FormFactor is buying and selling at a better a number of on an EV/EBITDA adjusted foundation in comparison with its closest friends. Intimately, our American participant is at the moment buying and selling at 16.4x with a 2024 estimated at nearly 20x. Technoprobe is at 15.98x and this larger discrepancy can be recorded on the price-earning degree (FormFactor at >30x vs Technoprobe at <25x). US new regulation might trim FormFactor export gross sales, and Technoprobe, with additionally more money for M&A optionality, ought to at the least deserve a premium valuation. Because of this, we imagine that FormFactor must be traded at a price-earnings ratio of not more than 19x, and with an implied 2023 EPS of $1.25, we arrive at a valuation of $23.75 per share. Due to this fact, we determined to lower our score to a promote.